brady_solicitors

Inherited service charge arrears: What to do when you take over from a previous managing agent 

Written by the Brady Solicitors Litigation Team. Brady Solicitors advises managing agents, freeholders, leaseholders, RTM companies and RMC directors on service charge recovery, block management disputes and residential leasehold litigation. 

When you take on a block and inherit a historic arrears schedule from the previous agent, there are four practical steps that should be taken. These are: audit each balance to establish what is owed and by whom; assess recoverability against the limitation period, the validity of the previous agent’s demands and section 20B; obtain the freeholder’s or RMC’s written decision on what to pursue and what to write off; and then instruct solicitors on everything to be pursued at the same time. 

Taking on a block with historic arrears is a situation we deal with regularly. The decisions made in the first few months tend to determine whether the position is resolved efficiently or becomes an expensive problem that follows the incoming agent for years. 

Step 1: Audit the inherited service charge arrears 

Before doing anything else, we recommend going through the arrears schedule and establishing for each balance: 

  • the demand periods it covers; 
  • who the registered leaseholder was when each demand became due and payable; 
  • whether the demands were validly served; 
  • whether there has been any dispute or correspondence about the balance; and 
  • whether a payment plan is in place, and if so, on what terms. 

This information is rarely complete in a handover pack. Some will emerge from leaseholders and some may require a formal request to the previous agent. For guidance on what to request from the previous agent, and what to do if they refuse, see our article on what a managing agent is legally required to hand over. 

From a managing agent’s perspective, the gaps matter as much as the figures. A balance that cannot be supported by evidence of a valid demand is not straightforwardly recoverable, whatever the schedule says. 

Step 2: Which inherited service charge arrears are recoverable? 

Once you have the picture, we suggest applying four filters to each balance. 

Limitation period. The applicable limitation period depends on the terms of the lease and the nature of the obligation. Although claims under a lease executed as a deed may be subject to a 12-year limitation period, claims for service charges reserved as rent will generally be subject to a six-year period. Each balance should therefore be considered individually. A payment or written acknowledgment may affect the limitation period in certain circumstances, but this should not be assumed without checking the position. 

Demand validity. Under section 47 of the Landlord and Tenant Act 1987, each service charge demand must state the landlord’s name and address and, if that address is not in England and Wales, an address in England and Wales at which notices can be served. Under section 21B of the Landlord and Tenant Act 1985, each demand must be accompanied by a summary of the leaseholder’s rights and obligations in the prescribed form. 

Where a demand failed either requirement, the leaseholder is entitled to withhold payment, and any interest or late-payment provisions in the lease do not apply, until a demand meeting those requirements is served. For the separate question of the section 48 notice of an address for service, and what to do when the previous agent’s address was used, see our article on protecting yourself when taking over a block. 
 
The position may differ where demands are issued by an RTM company, which is not necessarily the landlord. The requirements applicable to each demand should therefore be checked by reference to the identity of the party issuing it and the relevant statutory provisions. 

Section 20B. This is often the decisive filter for inherited arrears. Under section 20B of the Landlord and Tenant Act 1985, costs incurred more than 18 months before a demand is served are generally not recoverable unless the leaseholder was notified in writing within that 18-month window that the costs had been incurred and would be demanded. 

Certain defects in a demand may be capable of remedy, including failures to comply with sections 47 and 21B. However, whether a defective demand satisfies section 20B will depend on the nature of the defect and the circumstances. Particular care is needed where the demand was not valid under the terms of the lease. Where costs were not demanded within 18 months of being incurred, and no valid section 20B notification was given, recovery may be prevented. 

Property ownership. Where a flat has been sold, it is important to establish who was liable when the relevant charges became payable. Although arrears do not ordinarily become the personal liability of the purchaser, they may remain recoverable from the former leaseholder. The prospects of recovery should therefore be assessed before any decision is made to write off the balance. 

For managing agents and freeholders, the practical point is simple: run every inherited balance through all four filters before anyone writes to the leaseholder about it. 

Step 3: Deciding what to pursue and what to write off 

Having assessed the position, the freeholder or RMC needs to make a deliberate decision about each balance. The incoming agent’s role is to set out the options clearly and make a recommendation; the decision belongs to the client and we recommend that it is recorded in writing. This matters not just for good practice but because a write-off that is not formally recorded can later be treated as a live balance by a successor agent, a new director or a buyer’s solicitor on a later sale. The authority to approve any write-off should be checked against the management agreement and the relevant company’s decision-making arrangements. 

It is also worth bearing in mind the message a write-off may send to other leaseholders in the block. Where a substantial balance is removed from the accounts without explanation, those who have paid promptly may, where the lease permits, end up funding the shortfall through the service charge. That is a compelling reason not to defer the decision. 

For balances that are recoverable, the decision on whether to pursue them should take into account the cost relative to the amount owed, the strength of the evidence, and the leaseholder’s current circumstances. These are judgment calls that benefit from early legal input: understanding the legal position before any demand goes out allows the client to make an informed decision rather than a reactive one. 

Why pursuing recent arrears first may create problems 

A common and often costly mistake when dealing with inherited arrears is pursuing the recent, clean debt first and leaving the historic balance for later. 

The logic of doing so is understandable: recent arrears are often well-documented and the prospects of recovery more straightforward. Historic arrears may be messy and the limitation position uncertain. So the instruction comes in: recover this year’s service charge, and we will think about the rest later. 

Where recent and historic arrears are pursued in separate proceedings, there may be a risk of an abuse of process argument, particularly where the claims could reasonably have been brought together. However, this is not an automatic consequence and will depend on the circumstances. There may also be additional costs associated with bringing separate claims. The risk is real however, and the court may penalise the claimant in costs for the unnecessary duplication, within the limits of the track the claim is allocated to. It is also simply more expensive to run two sets of proceedings than one. 

For managing agents and freeholders we recommend carrying out the full audit first, obtaining the freeholder’s or RMC’s written decision on the whole position, and then instructing solicitors on everything to be pursued at the same time. If the historic balance is to be written off, we recommend recording that decision before issuing on the recent debt. 

Step 4: Sequencing recovery and when to involve solicitors 

Where both recent and historic arrears are being pursued under the same lease, care should be taken before accepting instalments or entering into payment arrangements. These can have legal consequences and should be considered carefully before terms are agreed. 

There is also a timing consideration. In the first few months of new management, leaseholders are often more receptive to a direct approach. An incoming agent who writes promptly, acknowledges the historic position, and offers a clear path to resolution may resolve a proportion of inherited balances without proceedings. 

One practical point that is often missed: we recommend that the first direct letter to leaseholders about inherited arrears goes out in the freeholder’s or RMC’s name. Where that letter is itself a demand, it will need to meet the section 47 and section 21B requirements. A fresh start that begins with a defective demand adds another sum the leaseholder is entitled to withhold. 

On the broader question of when to involve solicitors, our answer is usually that this should be done earlier than a lot of agents do it. Not to issue proceedings immediately, but to have the legal position assessed while the options are still open. 

For managing agents and freeholders, we recommend using the early window to engage leaseholders directly, but taking advice before accepting instalments or issuing on any balance while the historic position is still undecided. 

Inherited arrears rarely resolve themselves, but they are also rarely as intractable as they first look. If you have recently taken over a block with outstanding historic arrears and are unsure how to approach them, please get in touch and our team will be happy to help. 

Frequently asked questions

Can a new managing agent recover service charge arrears from before they took over? 

Generally yes, provided the arrears are within the limitation period, the original demands were (or can be) validly served, and the costs were demanded within 18 months of being incurred or a section 20B notice was given in time. The position depends on the individual balance and the lease. 

Do service charge arrears transfer to the buyer of a flat? 

Not ordinarily. Each service charge demand is generally the personal liability of whoever held the lease when it became due and payable. Whether a balance survived a sale depends on whether it was cleared or retained on completion. Balances that cannot be linked to the current leaseholder may need to be written off. 

Should we pursue recent arrears before historic ones? 

We recommend against it. Pursuing recent and historic arrears separately creates an abuse of process risk if the historic balance is later claimed in separate proceedings. We recommend carrying out a full audit, obtaining the freeholder’s or RMC’s written decision on the whole position, and instructing solicitors on everything to be pursued at the same time.

Get in touch with our experts

With hundreds of years’ worth of combined experience, our experts have dealt with nearly every leasehold property matter you can imagine. If you’re currently in need of legal support or advice, please get in touch.

Contact us
Two people discussing at computer