Image 2 (9)

How to protect yourself when taking over a block with a messy handover

Written by the Brady Solicitors Litigation Team. Brady Solicitors advises managing agents, freeholders, leaseholders, RTM companies and RMC directors on service charge recovery, block management disputes, and residential leasehold litigation. 

Taking over the management of a block rarely comes with a clean handover. More often, the incoming agent inherits an arrears schedule that does not reconcile, a set of records with gaps in it, an outgoing agent who is slow to respond, or leaseholders with concerns that should have been addressed some time ago.

This is a familiar position, and it is not necessarily a sign that anything has gone seriously wrong. Management contracts change hands regularly, and outgoing agents often do the minimum their contract requires. What determines the outcome, in our experience, is how the incoming agent responds in the first few months. Handled promptly and methodically, inherited problems remain the previous agent’s legacy and are usually manageable. Left to drift, they become the incoming agent’s own liability, and the window in which that distinction can still be drawn is a short one.

Before you accept the contract: What to ask for at the outset

The best time to establish what you will receive on handover is before you sign the management agreement, not after. Most management contracts include a termination clause specifying what must be returned on change of agent. The incoming agent rarely sees that clause. You should ask to see it as part of your due diligence.

You should also request a full handover pack as a condition of taking on the management. What that pack should contain is set out in our separate article on what an outgoing agent is required to hand over.

Requesting this before you start is not aggressive. It is good professional practice, and it puts you in a stronger position if anything is withheld. A freeholder or RMC board that cannot explain why the previous agent is refusing to cooperate is also a freeholder or RMC board you should think carefully about acting for.

Documenting everything from day one

Once you take over, your ability to recover arrears and deal with disputes depends almost entirely on the quality of your records. That means starting your own audit trail from the first day of your management, regardless of the state of what you have inherited.

Document every request made to the previous agent, every response, and every silence. We return below to why that record matters if the agent will not cooperate.

For arrears inherited from the previous management, establish a clear baseline. What is owed, for which demand periods, and by whom? Where a flat has since been sold, was the arrears position dealt with on completion? Where a leaseholder has since sold the flat, was the arrears position reflected in the completion statement? You will not be able to answer all of these questions immediately, but identifying the gaps is the first step to managing them.

The address position deserves particular attention. Where the lease incorporates section 196 of the Law of Property Act 1925, a notice is sufficiently served if left at the leaseholder’s last known address or affixed or left at the flat, so service at the property itself is good service under the section. Two caveats matter however. First, whether a service charge demand counts as a notice for this purpose depends on the lease’s own service provisions, not section 196 alone. Second, the Land Registry holds up to three addresses for service against each title. Those are the starting point for establishing a leaseholder’s last known address, and a demand sent to an address that matches neither the register nor the flat, with no record of where it came from, will be hard to defend. Where the correspondence address used by the previous agent differs from what the Land Registry shows, or from the flat address, verify and document the position before issuing any demand.

There is a further point that incoming agents frequently miss. If the address the freeholder gave leaseholders for service of notices under section 48 of the Landlord and Tenant Act 1987 was the previous agent’s office, that address stops working the day they leave. A fresh section 48 notice giving an address in England and Wales should be served on every leaseholder promptly; until it is, there is a real risk that service charges will be treated as not due. Separately, every demand must state the freeholder’s own name and address under section 47; the new agent’s address does not satisfy that.

The first few months: Why this window matters

There is a period, typically the first three to six months of new management, where the incoming agent has a credible basis to separate themselves from what happened before. Leaseholders who are frustrated with the state of the block may be more willing to engage with a new agent who acknowledges the problems and is visibly trying to sort them out than they will be with an agent who has been in place for a year and has not made progress.

This applies to arrears as much as it does to maintenance. Approaching a leaseholder in the first month, explaining that you have identified the balance and want to agree a way forward, is a very different conversation from the same approach six months later, when the arrears have grown on your watch.

Once this window closes, the inherited problems become your problems. A tribunal considering whether costs were reasonably incurred, or a client reviewing your performance under the management agreement, will not treat a problem differently because it predates your management if you have had eighteen months to address it.

When the previous agent will not cooperate

The most common difficulty incoming agents face is an outgoing agent who simply does not hand over what they should.

The starting point is a clear written request setting out precisely what you need and why, citing the handover expectations in the RICS Service Charge Residential Management Code. This should be sent promptly and by a method that creates a record. It should not be a general request for cooperation but a specific list: the documents, data, and information you require, with a deadline for response. If there is no response, or the response is incomplete, follow up in writing noting what is still outstanding.

This record is valuable for two reasons. First, it establishes that you have done everything reasonably required before escalating. Second, if the case reaches proceedings, the outgoing agent’s failure to respond to a clear, documented request will be relevant to any application for costs and to the court’s view of the dispute. If the outgoing agent refuses or fails to respond despite a clear request, these are the client’s rights to enforce, not the agent’s. The demand should go out in the name of the freeholder or RMC, and any proceedings will need to be issued by them. 

Protecting your own position: Insurance and liability

Taking on a block with an unclear arrears position or undocumented historic disputes creates potential liability for the incoming agent. If leaseholders have valid defences to historic arrears that arise from the previous agent’s conduct, those defences do not disappear because management has changed. If the previous agent served invalid demands or made concessions that were not documented, the incoming agent may find themselves in the middle of disputes that are not of their making.

Before taking on a block with significant inherited arrears or disputed history, check that your professional indemnity cover extends to the work you are being asked to do, including pursuing arrears that predate your management. PI policies generally require notification of circumstances that may give rise to a claim; if a problem emerges from the inherited position that could result in a claim against you, it should be notified promptly. It is also worth reviewing the limitation-of-liability wording in your management agreement in relation to matters predating your appointment.

Additionally, it is worth addressing the scope of your retainer with the client at the outset. If you are being asked to take on and pursue arrears that predate your management, make sure that instruction is in writing, that the client understands the limitations of what you can recover without the full demand history, and that your fees reflect the additional work involved.

Taking over a block: A short checklist

Before signing:

  • Ask to see the termination clause in the outgoing agent’s management agreement, and make a full handover pack a condition of your appointment.
  • Confirm with your insurers that your professional indemnity cover extends to pursuing arrears that predate your management.

In the first week:

  • Check whether the outgoing agent’s office has been used as the landlord’s address for service. If so, serve fresh section 47 and 48 notices, containing the landlord’s address, promptly to avoid future issues with the validity and recoverability of service charge demands.
  • Send the outgoing agent a specific, dated list of everything outstanding, in the client’s name, citing the RICS Code, and record every response or absence of one.
  • Get the client’s instructions on inherited arrears in writing, with your fees reflecting the additional work.

In the first three months:

  • Establish the arrears baseline: what is owed, for which periods, by whom, and whether any flats have changed hands since the demands fell due.
  • Verify every correspondence address against the Land Registry and the flat, and document where each one came from.
  • Record all inherited payment plans, disputes and live or contemplated proceedings in writing, and check whether any solicitors’ instructions need to transfer.
  • Contact every leaseholder in arrears while you can still credibly describe the position as inherited.

If the outgoing agent will not cooperate:

  • Have the client, not you, make the formal demand, and take advice on a section 42 claim for retained funds or a claim for delivery up of documents.

Taking on a block with a messy handover is manageable if it is approached promptly and methodically. The problems that become expensive and contested are almost always the ones that were left to drift.

If you are in the early stages of a transition that is not going smoothly, or if you have taken over a block and are facing resistance from the previous agent, please do get in touch and one of our team will be happy to help.

Get in touch with our experts

With hundreds of years’ worth of combined experience, our experts have dealt with nearly every leasehold property matter you can imagine. If you’re currently in need of legal support or advice, please get in touch.

Contact us
Two people discussing at computer